Determining the metal of a coin

Written on March 26, 2011 • Last edit: March 18, 2019
See the French article

Measuring the density
Testing with a magnet

Measuring the density

A coin density is the ratio between the coin's weight and the weight of the same volume of water. This ratio varies from one metal to another and its calculation is more accurate when dealing with pure metals (silver, gold, zinc, etc.) and heavier coins. When dealing with silver, the density calculation can help determine fineness.

Keep in mind that this method may not be fully accurate, specifically for low weight coins. You may want to use other methods to confirm or not the metal of a coin.

Equipment to measure a coin's density

Measuring a coin's density will require few easy steps and some basic equipment:
  • A precision scale (0.01 g) with tare option;
  • A glass filled with water;
  • A paper clip;
  • A piece of string, 10 to 20 cm long.

Process to measure a coin's density

Now that your equipment is ready, eight steps will help you gather the data needed to perform the density calculation. These steps are illustrated below and involves the following actions:
  1. Weight the coin and write down its weight.
  2. Tie the string to the paper clip.
  3. Put the glass of water on the scale.
  4. Put the clip fully under water while suspended to the string. Make sure the clip makes no direct contact with the glass.
  5. Set the scale tare (i.e. set it to 0, with the clip fully immersed in the glass of water still on the scale).
  6. Put the coin in the clip. If the coin is too large, bend the clip and set the coin on top of it.
  7. Put the coin and clip fully under water. Make sure they make no direct contact with the glass.
  8. Write down the new weight displayed on the scale.

For the above illustrated example, the coin's weight is 6.51 grams while the weight of the equivalent volume of water is 0.79 grams.

Calculation of a coin's density

Once you are done with the above process, you should be left with two weights on paper. All you need to do now is dividing the initial weight of the sole coin by the weight of the immersed coin, and compare your ratio with common metals' densities values as follows:
  • Gold - 19.32
  • Silver - 10.49
  • Nickel or Copper - 8.9
  • Iron - 7.87
  • Zinc - 7.13
  • Aluminium - 2.70

The below tool will help you to automatically calculate this ratio and figure out the coin's metal. To use it enter both weights without decimals, meaning in our case we would enter 651 and 79 (rather than 6.51 and 0.79). The red dot appearing on the graph will give you an indication of what kind of metal you have in hand.

Coin's weight [1] Additional weight
when coin in water [2]
÷ = ?

Testing with a magnet

This is one of the most common and easy test to perform. Although this test does not give you the metal directly, it can help you quickly eliminate a large number of metals and alloys.

Process of the magnet test

This test does not require any specific equipment except, of course, a magnet. You just have to approach your coin of the magnet to get an answer track:
  1. If the coin is attracted by the magnet, then it is made of a magnetic metal or alloy.
  2. If the coin is not attracted by the magnet, then it is made of a non-magnetic metal or alloy.

Metals and alloys

  • Iron, steel
  • Nickel, copper-nickel
  • Cobalt

The attraction of cupronickel by the magnet will depend on the nickel content. Below 25% nickel, the magnet will attract the coin less or even not at all.

  • Copper, brass, bronze
  • Stainless steel
  • Lead
  • Tin
  • Aluminium
  • Silver
  • Gold

Conclusion of the magnet test

The exact composition of a coin can not be directly known thanks to the magnet test. This test makes it possible to eliminate some metals and alloys according to the result, or to confirm the coherence between the coin in hand and its official composition. It also allows in some cases to determine if a coin is fake. Thus, a gold or silver coin which is attracted by the magnet, will necessarily be fake; these metals not being magnetic.